Just Kasher it
Though I am late to the fray on this particular story, I’m catching up on my Forward reading and was struck by this article. The Conservative rabbinate has recently, and rightly, begun an examination of the working conditions within kosher food plants after hearing reports of inappropriate labor practices.
Rabbi Gershon Tannenbaum, a columnist for an Orthodox periodical, said Jews should “repulse any attempts of introducing such alien impositions…[and that the] injection of social or humanitarian considerations, especially by outsiders, would be an unallowable breach of the time honored halachic administration of kashrus standards.”
I’m offended, frankly. It’s as if social and humanitarian considerations are an added burden in the pursuit of a truly Jewish life. Everything I’ve learned, and what I love about my Judaism, is that social and humanitarian considerations are the foundation of Jewish values. It makes me wonder what is more important to them: the rules or the intention.
Further on in the article, one gets the impression that the Orthodox are willing to play to make enemies left and right with this one.
The rabbinic administrator at the Central Rabbinical Congress, Yitzchok Glick, told the Forward that he had spoken with kosher companies and told them not to permit Conservative rabbis into their factories.
“We said that they shouldn’t allow them in,” Glick said. “The Orthodox kosher producers are all of the same opinion. They will adhere to our proclamation. They will not allow them into the plant.”
For all my disagreement, I’m happy to see this dust-up happen. For me, Kashrut is about knowing where your food came from, respecting the people who grew or slaughtered it for you, making it without the use of hormones and pesticides, and blessing the bounty God has provided at every point. I welcome the Conservative rabbis’ attempts to reach a more just agreement on Kashrut, and it may just turn me into one myself!
Full disclosure: My fiancee and I disagree on Kashrut. She wants to do it; I think the rules are just rules for rules sake. But with changes like these happening, I might be persuaded to Kasher our home.
Digg This!
Technorati
Del.icio.us
Furl
Blinklist
Ma.gnolia
Yahoo! My Web